Here we are on the final day of September and I still do not miss the classroom. I really thought I would miss writing with students, and perhaps I will, but I have leaned so hard into writing in/with different communities that perhaps it is understandable that I don’t miss the classroom. Right now I am finding great joy in being a student and challenging myself as a poet so it would have to be a pretty special teaching opportunity to lure me back. Especially as all the forces of evil that make education a nightmare are still fresh in my mind. However, this might be the perfect perspective for me to consider some of the pedagogical choices I’ve written about that were often made in the heat of the moment and in response to a variety of pressures. It is certainly worth exploring from the cool perspective of retirement – especially as a writer who is currently more student than teacher.
Throughout my years in the classroom I have always cared a lot more about the writer than I have about the writing product because the disposable writing produced for an assignment was always going to be ephemeral, but I know from my own journey as a writer that there are lessons we always carry with us – for good and for bad reasons. That is why over the years I came to focus more and more on authentic writing as well as offering students the freedom to create something unique, meaningful, and fun. Sometimes this meant writing slant because I wanted to see my students’ writing and rhetoric in the wild.
I have never been one for teaching developing writers rules engraved on stone tablets and that was clear when I wrote 7 Rules for Teaching Writers and Students Don’t Need “Our” Writing Rules. That is why I wrote Let’s Stop Calling It The Writing Process and eventually landed on an entirely different metaphor for writing in It’s A Journey Not A Process. I have always been much more interested in the authentic writing that comes when the writer not only understands their rhetorical context but controls it. This long-standing belief is also why I left modes behind for themes and leaned into the narrative argument. I have always believed that engaging in lots of low stakes writing practice is perhaps the most important rule any writing teacher should stress.
That is also how games came to play such a large role in the final decade of my teaching career. In the Spring 2019 semester when I fully committed to building an entire class around games (see Games and Writing), I learned that games could indeed bring us together as a community and help us become better thinkers and writers. My initial three reasons for bringing games into the classroom still remain true. Playing as well as thinking, talking, and writing about games offers so many wonderful opportunities to explore humanity so we can better consider our rhetorical context (especially audience) and brought so much joy into my writing classroom. Every semester students would learn amazing writing lessons from considering games from a rhetorical perspective. While my gaming of the teaching of writing evolved over the years, I still love to share that journey with other teachers because I strongly encourage every teacher, but especially teachers of writing, to begin gaming their classroom!
However, there was a pedagogical journey before I leaned fully into games that includes embracing pop culture as a way to explore the themes and questions humans always seek to address with their stories. Along the way I made my composition classes textbook-free zones and embraced poetry (put a pin in that) and This I Believe essays and other open online texts to serve as mentors for my student writers. Both This I Believe and pop culture were also an important part of my American Creed work. Pop culture as well as games were also pivotal when it came to teaching rhetorical analysis which is one of the most important lessons I taught although good faith argument comes a close second. Pop culture and rhetorical analysis were essential to informing my students about rhetorical context and audience analysis.
One of the major shifts in my pedagogy caused by the pandemic was the centering of poetry in my composition classroom. While I first began using poetry as an invitation to write I eventually began using poetry as a tool for teaching rhetorical context and reflection as well as writing technique. Good poetry has much to teach writers about word choice and audience awareness as well as a variety of other rhetorical strategies, so I loved struggling through the process of selecting the perfect poem that could provide both inspiration and edification from One Poem To Rule Them All to A Poetic Invitation to High Voltage Warning.
Finally, reflection has always played an important role in my writing life as well as the way I teach writing (Exhibit A is this blog). Earlier this year I wrote that reflection is the answer to almost any pedagogical question because I have witnessed the powerful impact of reflection on student writers. I have always wanted my students to explore their own literacy journey and for many years that meant the literacy narrative was an essential assignment. My literacy narrative assignment changed over the years as I explored how other educators used it in the classroom. Which led me to offer students choice in how they approached their own literacy narrative. I loved bracketing my semester with the literacy narrative assignment and then wrapping up with a final reflection. Then as I began changing my approach to grading as well as teaching writing I leaned into the transliteracy reflection because I wanted my students to consider their literacy experience in the world at large – not just the classroom. In the final years of my teaching career we reflected weekly on our challenges and progress as writers and then students chose their own approach to examine their journey as a writer. Reading those reflections were powerful for me as a teacher and writing those reflections were instructive for my students. Highly recommend.
And now for the 10 great pedagogical choices I promised:
- Learning to write is important but that doesn’t mean it can’t be fun as well as meaningful.
- Writing slant essays was an important shift for me and my students.
- One of the most important lessons I taught my writing students was that growing as a writer was a lifelong journey.
- Learning to analyze texts is an important part of understanding rhetorical context.
- Low stakes writing practice is essential to developing writers.
- How To Begin Gaming Your Classroom continues to hold up as solid advice for other teachers as well as one of the best pedagogical choices I made as a teacher of writers, rhetoricians, and humans.
- Rhetorical analysis was always one of my favorite units to teach first year writers as teaching students to look beneath the hood of a text and examine its impact on the audience offered so much opportunity to learn and grow as humans and writers.
- Teaching my students, as both writers and humans, to engage in good faith arguments was such an important mission and much more important than many of the trivial writing rules many folks want to prioritize.
- Another great pedagogical decision was to make poetry, especially that of living poets, the primary text in my composition classrooms and that is why High Voltage Warning remains good advice for all writing teachers.
- Landing on Reflection is the Answer was a real struggle for me as 10 Ways Literacy Narratives Will Rock Your World has always been both a favorite assignment but also a favorite blog post. I never stopped assigning the literacy narrative because I stopped loving it! I felt less strongly about Transliteracy Reflections but recognize the importance of that experience on my journey as a teacher. While I will not include these blog posts on my top list, I want to mention them here (and I posted a note on Reflection is the Answer) because they are important.
Image by TheAndrasBarta from Pixabay

