Teacher Evaluation is the Worst

I am in my final weeks as a full-time writing instructor and looking forward to my third act. I don’t know what will become of this space because once I’ve stepped out of the student-teacher feedback loop I am not certain how relevant my advice will be. Is there anything worse than advice from someone whose classroom management experience is in the past (other than, of course, advice from someone with no classroom management experience)? I’m not certain what my third act will bring (other than reading, watching, and writing in community) but right now I certainly do not feel any urge to engage in professional development leadership. Been there, done that, and as much as I believe in the National Writing Project I am very much opposed to the teacher evaluation industry as a whole because it does not foster good teaching and professional development is too closely linked to that evaluation industry for my comfort.

Maybe I’ll change my mind after some months of rest and escape from the relentless academic evaluation grind, but my wounds are still raw and bleeding from my last official teacher evaluation (received weeks ago). The evaluation wasn’t bad, but it also wasn’t great and I blame a system that leans in on the measurable (which for some reason means student evaluation metrics – is there anything more insane than this?) and somehow privileges the rare student complaint while dismissing the multitude of enthusiastic student endorsements. Granted this is somewhat my fault. As this was my last evaluation I did not submit any narrative and I did not not participate in the observation process, but my department has developed a form and process that does not lend itself to the narrative or any “evidence” that does not serve the form. Plus, I’m retiring for goodness sake!!! I was not phoning in my classroom instruction, just an irrelevant evaluation process. This experience would be easier to shrug off if not did not represent my evaluation history at this institution.

Most of my career at this institution there has been no real effort to evaluate my praxis or engage in nurturing my growth as a teacher. Several chairs have never ever set foot in my classroom and, to my knowledge, the only student feedback they hear are complaints. I have only had one department chair who regularly observed my teaching and engaged in thoughtful discussion of my choices. Most often the annual evaluation process has been conducted in a defensive crouch as my job or teaching load was on the line (by explicit or implicit message) due to outside forces (beyond my control or that of my direct supervisor). The aforementioned department form was developed by faculty who do not actually value teaching and especially the teaching of writing so what is the point of putting time and effort into that process? What is the point of a teacher evaluation that doesn’t offer meaningful feedback and financial reward?

The most effective evaluations have been when I engaged in peer evaluation methods with colleagues whose values are similar to my own. I love learning from other educators and often have found inspiration when involved in one of these peer evaluation exchanges. Thanks to my work with the National Writing Project I have often observed teachers who teach different content and grade levels and I wish more of my peer evaluation experience had incorporated this type of experience.

There is also a real problem, exacerbating all the other problems, with the way that teacher evaluation (faculty evaluation in particular) is conducted: student evaluations are often a dominant force and we do not engage with students enough to help them conduct good teacher evaluation (and usually the instruments for this evaluation are terrible). Even worse, we do not put any meaningful work into sifting out the truly problematic teacher-student dynamic from the disgruntled student with few opportunities to offer institutional feedback. The American education system (P-16) is broken and the way we conduct teacher evaluation only makes it worse. We could create meaningful feedback loops to help educators grow and feel supported, but we choose not to do so because our entire education system is built on oppressive conformity rather than fostering success.

I am not a perfect teacher and certainly not a perfect fit for every student, but it is a devastating critique of our education system that the only humans who offered me true appreciation and understanding of my teaching methods are my students. This is not just about my humane classroom policies, but much more about my focus on reflection as the answer to the problems of grading developing writers. Just as my student writers engage in continual feedback loops as they draft I also engage in continual feedback loops as well as reflection as I teach. That is how I found my teaching sweet spot and will retire knowing that I am at the height of my powers as a writing instructor even if my administration has no idea what they are losing. I chose to skip the college recognition of my service because these ceremonies focus on the clock and not the individual. I could not sit still and quiet during this perfunctory performance. I will instead say farewell to colleagues over a quick slice of cake before packing up my office and turning in my keys. Then, as my energy and emotional capacity allows, I will sift through the student reflections of my final year of teaching for lessons that I think might offer advice for other writing teachers via this blog. After that who knows…feel free to make requests or suggestions. I do know that I will miss regular interaction with young people and I worry about the implications for my state of mind. The right invitation or opportunity might persuade me out of retirement for a day or a week, but right now I have no interest in a long-term gig.

Image by Tom from Pixabay

Author: Deanna Mascle
Freshly retired (July 2026) after teaching writers and writing teachers at Morehead State University (KY) since 2001. National Writing Project teacher (and former site director) since 2008. LexPoMo since 2016. Founding leader of Write Across America and Rebel Cartographers (2020).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.