Reflection is the answer to almost any pedagogical challenge.
I have put forward building community as the most important goal for teachers and I still believe this is true, but every community has to have a purpose and reflection is essential as both roadmap and measurement toward that goal. The National Writing Project has given me many gifts through the years, but perhaps teaching me to be a reflective practitioner might be the most important. This is often the gift that I look for in other educators to know if they will become National Writing Project teacher leaders.
One of the gifts that my practice retirement has given me is the time and space for more reflection. However, I am still engaged enough in the practice of teaching to know the struggles facing both learners and educators. All our brains are broken (thanks tech bros for the gift that keeps giving) which means that we are not reading enough long form texts as well as failing to engage in long form storytelling (movies, narrative television, etc.) in general. This is not good for our literacy or our humanity and so should be viewed as an existential threat, but sure let’s argue about the dancers in the Superbowl halftime show instead of the amazing artistry and storytelling. Also, the way we teach writing in the US is also broken and just plain wrongheaded. We can again blame the techbros who pushed books and writing on paper out of the classroom, but there is also plenty of blame for Bush’s No Child Left Behind and Obama’s Race to the Top which left programs like NWP unfunded and every teacher focused on testing to destruction. I digress, but not really because decades of focusing on technology and testing mean that generations of educators and students only see reading and writing as static measurable things rather than ways of thinking that are valuable just for themselves.
Writing in community is a powerful way to help writers learn and grow, but also way to remember the magic of human stories. Engaging in the regular practice of writing is the only way to develop as a writer, but I knew long before NWP that we all need a writing community to both keep us honest and to inspire us. However, the simple act of writing and sharing is not enough. We need to learn how to set goals for our writing and how to measure our progress. This is where reflection becomes so important.
My long journey with the practice of ungrading led me to center reflection and self assessment in my classes. I haven’t put a grade on a piece of writing for years and yet most of my students can write long reflections about what they learned about writing and, most important, think about writing. I teach my students that developing as a writer is a lifelong journey and introduce them to the tools they will need for that journey.
Students tell me this practice of writing and reflecting in community is both healing and empowering. I also know that this practice is a terrific antidote to the use of artificial intelligence tools. On my syllabus I have an anti-AI policy, but I know it is my teaching practice that centers human writing and reflection that is the real guardrail. How often do your students reflect about their writing journey? Can you name a pedagogical challenge that is not solved by reflection?
Update: A few weeks later I was feeling beaten down by a recent evaluation (because my administration does not see what I do in the classroom and its impact) but then I opened up a student reflection that reminded me of why I do what I do in specific and glorious detail. As I fast approach retirement I know I will never be fully seen by my administration but my students see and appreciate what I am doing. That is the power of the final reflection essay. My students learn from that examination of their work and growth, but it is also a balm for my soul.
Final Update: I’m retired as of July 1, 2026, and one of my third act goals is to re-vision what this blog and all it contains will become. This includes sifting and sorting through hundreds of posts to identify my favorite posts and the advice I think will be most helpful to the educators still in the classroom. So far I’ve identified my favorite blog posts about writing, learning, and being human as well as my favorite posts about writing community. For the next few weeks I will revisit some of my favorite lessons to identify the best. Reflection has always been one of the most important tools in my pedagogical toolbox from 10 Ways Literacy Narratives Will Rock Your World (or at least your writing classroom) to Transliteracy Reflections. Both assignments were important stops on my journey as a teacher of writers and helped me discover my own sweet spot as a teacher. This leaves me to note that your own sweet spot as a teacher will not (and should not) look like mine, but I urge you to explore some of the way stations I visited on my journey.
Image by Monika Iris from Pixabay

