What have I learned?

I officially retired July 1 and have spent the intervening months curating my hundreds of blog posts spanning the last 15 years of a teaching career that officially began in 1987. I am still not sure what to do with this blog and all the lessons I have learned from a lifetime of learning to be human, writer, and teacher. In many ways this blog has always been the ultimate vanity project, a personal journey where I worked on the challenges of living, writing, and teaching in real time. I probably should shape it into something more handy, but right now I really don’t want to spend my time on that endeavor. There are books to read and poetry to write! Hopefully someone will find some benefit from this review of the forces that shaped me as a teacher and the gems that resulted from those pressures.

After submitting my last set of grades I wrote Grades Are Stupid which is a hill I have been prepared to die on for much of my teaching career as I first struggled to lower the stakes in my writing classroom through grading with forms, collaborative assessment, grade conferences, and gamification which ultimately led me to ungrading. Every teacher has to find the right balance of grace in their teaching praxis and I hope that more teachers will consider ways to lower the stakes in their classroom by not making grades do more than they can.

Maybe it is my undiagnosed ADHD or maybe it is simply my teaching philosophy, but I hate that so often I was forced to track attendance, even though we all know that seat time is not pedagogy, or forced by departmental mandate to make my students complete terrible writing assignments. My entire teaching career has been a fight against disposable writing because why would I require writing that my students do not want to write and I do not want to read? What exactly is the point of any of that? I have long focused more on deliverables in place of assignments and striving for each class activity to serve multiple purposes for developing writers. This is all fruit of the same poisonous tree that uses student shaming as a classroom management device.

I taught first year college writing almost every year since I began working full-time in higher education in 2000 and loved so much of that experience. I was lucky enough to retire still loving the experience when I taught my last class. Just last night I spent time with my favorite department chair and after a delightful evening I mulled over the depressing fact my last positive experience with professional evaluation was under his supervision decades ago. Teacher evaluation is the not the worst part of the terrible broken education system, but it can all too often break teachers just when we need every one. Worst of all it does not help teachers learn and grow so the struggling can become the rock stars our students deserve.

Of course, the problem is systemic because we have long outsourced our education system to the capitalists which requires us to test to destruction and put kids in boxes instead of harnessing the creative genius inherent in every human. Capitalism wants us to create consumers not curators and creators and that, my friends, is a big problem. in 2024 I wrote Unique, meaningful, and fun to celebrate the wonderful creativity and innovation I saw in my classroom when students are given the agency to use rhetoric for their own purposes. We have let the oligarchs run our schools for too long and we have lost sight of the greater good. AI is just the latest of the ways that the techbro oligarchy has brought ruin to education, but I found ways to stop the invasion at my classroom door so I know it can be done.

Ironically, one of the ways I found to combat the standardized systems foisted on us by the oligarchs who own modern education is through systems. I am not opposed to systems that are locally driven and there is nothing more local than a classroom community. My journey toward a systems approach to teaching was long and certainly not smooth, but I have zero regrets about incorporating hyperdocs into my classes for the last decade of my teaching career. I think my undiagnosed ADHD may be one of the reasons I’ve always been drawn to systems but we can also draw a straight line back to my computer programming education in the 1980s. I have been both an online educator and online student and my entry into the field of online education fully recognized the power of distance learning and not even the terrible way we handled pandemic education has shaken my belief. Given my own choice I love a hybrid class so I can meet my students where they are, but I know that I can build community both in person and online.

One of the great struggles of my teaching career has been the numbers game – the number of classes on my contract and the number of students on my rosters. Much of my career those numbers have had little to do with the human capacity of myself to teach writing and my students to work within a writing community, but no matter what the oligarchs and administrators who worship them think – class size matters. However, the sad truth is that we have no control over the numbers that drive us to exhaustion and beyond the breaking point. The only thing we have in our control is how we personally respond to the broken system. While we all have the urge to do more, because there is always someone more broken and burned, we must resist that urge because our fingers in the dam will never stop the wall from breaking. Teachers must always always always put our oxygen mask on first. One of the ways that I practiced self care was to actively resist the ridiculous demands of the system by focusing on teaching delight. My primary teaching load included required classes that most students resented taking and made even worse by institutional forces that could not be bothered to understand what developing writers truly need. Teaching toward that sweet spot was the only thing that saved me and my students in those final brutal years. One of the best lessons I learned early was to recognize the difference between way stations and weigh stations or rather when you need to check in with the writer and when you need to check in with the writing. I worked for years to find a solution to the last mile problem.

As a writer I often find great inspiration when writing within a certain constraint. It is one of the reason I have written so many poems to form (think sonnet or haiku), but as you may already have noticed the constraints that our education system and far too many educators within it want to place on students just makes my head and heart hurt. Checklists and chores have driven all creativity and fun out of so much learning especially when it comes to writing. That is what led me to lean into themes to support my writing instruction. However, it is the marriage between themes (that provide the constraint) and project-based learning that truly changed the way I think about learning and writing in both my own creative life as well as classroom. Some of my best experiences as either a teacher or learner have taken place in various incarnations of makerspaces. Speaking of useful constraints I need to celebrate the six-word story as a gift for reflection and focus. I used it constantly in my classroom and in my personal life and it will forever hold a piece of my heart.

ADHD comes with a lot of downsides but one of the true benefits, in my experience, is that we never lose that beginner’s mindset which is really a superpower as a teacher. I just realized that is also going to be a tremendous resource in my third act. Believing that teachers need to be learners has always been a corrnerstone practice as a National Writing Project teacher leader and a piece of advice I will always give to teachers. One of the best lessons I learned as a teacher (and human) was that we reap what we sow. I wrote in that blog post that as a teacher I am comfortable planting seeds I may never see grow and now on the other side of retirement I am well content with my season of sowing.

The goals I used to measure my praxis were simple: did I help my students grow as writers, thinkers, and humans? The most important forces that shaped that praxis include:

  • I do not regret my long assessment journey, because I learn through spiraling (sometimes tangled) trials, in every definition of the word. I also do not apologize for my former students who sometimes suffered through these experiments because I believe through these iterations I modeled my belief in the way learning and education should be because at the end of the day the educators I respect can all agree Grades Are Stupid.
  • Teaching is demanding and messy with a million distractions and so it is very important that we hold onto some guidelines to keep us from being lost in the blizzard and one of mine has always been focusing on the process more than the product. I have always believed focusing too much on the product will always derail a developing writer and sour the learning/teaching experience.
  • I have never wanted to focus on time and energy on policing my students and have always felt that one of my jobs as a writing teacher is to be a cheerleader and hype woman. I have written often about all the negative baggage so many students bring into their writing classes and that is why I believe student shaming is bad for everyone involved in the practice.
  • The more that the oligarchs dictate how we should teach and measure and simply make us all mass market consumers the more that I lean into choosing my own adventure and when I offered that opportunity to my students by challenging them to create something unique, meaningful, and fun the rewards for all were tremendous.
  • Teacher evaluation is the worst because it does very little and is often runs counter to supporting teacher growth and improvement. Much like the problems we encounter when it comes to student assessment the focus is on what can be quantified rather than what we should really value.
  • Very early in my career at Morehead State University I pitched and piloted online first year writing classes because I saw a need. I spent decades learning to be a good online teacher and even before the pandemic understood well the advantages of hybrid classes. As both a learner and an educator I believe in the power of online education while also recognizing that many times it is not done well – which is of course true of in person education too.
  • The only thing that saved my sanity in those final stressful years of my career was focusing on teaching delight through both my content and classroom choices. Highly recommend every teacher find as many ways as possible to do the same.
  • I know I’ve already addressed evaluation twice but we all know that it is one of the most crushing forces in education. One of the best questions I asked myself is to consider whether the class needed a way station or a weigh station on any given day.
  • There is always tension between the amount of control and agency at play in every classroom and I found early on that I liked the balance between deploying themes for my writing classes while simultaneously offering the freedom of project-based learning. The combination was truly magical in my experience.
  • I have always possessed a passion for learning and that has been one of my driving forces as a teacher. If you do not possess a beginner’s mindset I strongly suggest you cultivate one.

Image by ENRIC SAGARRA from Pixabay – selected because learning to be a teacher is both art and craft but always always always very very very messy.

Author: Deanna Mascle
Freshly retired (July 2026) after teaching writers and writing teachers at Morehead State University (KY) since 2001. National Writing Project teacher (and former site director) since 2008. LexPoMo since 2016. Founding leader of Write Across America and Rebel Cartographers (2020).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.